11 April 2011
The Church of England has expressed concern that the
Government's child poverty strategy unveiled last week will not
help the deprived children of today and has called for a renewed
focus on household income.
The Mission and Public Affairs division of the Archbishops'
Council said in a statement released today: "We regret that the
strategy contains no intention to redistribute wealth at a time
when material inequality in Britain is higher than it has been for
over a century."
It added that the new Government measures would not have
immediate effect "and our strongest concerns are reserved for the
outcomes experienced by children now".
While the Church supports the Government view that effective
parenting, strong families with at least one parent in work, access
to good education and good life chances are vitally important for
all children. It believes that any child poverty strategy has to
focus on household income "because, in practices and despite all
the other factors which affect childrens' wellbeing, money
matters."
The statement adds: "Whilst time is allowed for social mobility
to become a reality for all, we have to make sure our children do
not suffer in the short or medium term."
The Bishop of Southwark, the Rt Revd Christopher Chessun, Bishop
for Urban Life and Faith said: "Child poverty is a persistent
problem within our society. Family and pre-school poverty
left unaddressed seriously inhibits the opportunities children have
to reach their potential. Child poverty is a family matter that
challenges fundamental values which underpin our life
together in community. We welcome the Government's initiative to
develop policies that are seeking to find ways of alleviating child
poverty.
The ever present problems of poverty cannot be ignored. It
is essential that when national government and local
authorities look at cuts the problems of everyday poverty faced by
children and their families are not forgotten. The need to tackle
child poverty cannot be shelved as if it is a problem for the
future; it is one that needs to be overcome with policies that have
an immediate impact. I hope that the Government will set out clear
targets designed to eradicate this evil and be willing to be held
accountable to them"
The full statement is below:
Even in the current climate of austerity there is a
responsibility to ensure that the welfare of children is maximised
in any system of benefits and allocation of resources from the
public purse. In its new child poverty strategy announced today the
Government sets out how it intends to do that; addressing what it
considers to be the root causes of poverty based on the firm
conviction that poverty is about more than income. Rather than
tackling inequality through a redistribution of wealth, the
Government intends to tackle child poverty through improving social
mobility, changing welfare provisions to make work pay and
decentralising services to make them more targeted. In order
to measure its success, the Government has set out new child
poverty indicators. These will be grouped around household income,
parental employment and children's life chances.
The Church of England welcomes the intention to focus on the
root causes of poverty and agrees that incentives to find work are
important in tackling entrenched views about work in some
communities. We are also supportive of the Government's intention
to improve social mobility and welcome its long term strategy to
enable each person to reach their potential whatever the
circumstances of their birth. However these measures will not have
immediate effect and our strongest concerns are reserved for the
outcomes experienced by children now.
Effective parenting, strong families with at least one parent in
work, access to good education and good life chances are vitally
important for all children. However we believe any child poverty
strategy has to focus on household income because, in practices and
despite all the other factors which affect childrens' wellbeing,
money matters. Whilst time is allowed for social mobility to become
a reality for all, we have to make sure our children do not suffer
in the short or medium term.
We regret that the strategy contains no intention to
redistribute wealth at a time when material inequality in Britain
is higher than it has been for over a century. Inequality, at least
as much as absolute definitions of poverty, has been shown to be
detrimental to the wellbeing of children and families. The cuts in
social benefits, including a 3-year freeze on child benefit, have a
cumulative effect on the income of families with children. This is
therefore a matter of great concern, particularly in a climate of
stagnation where the job market is not growing and a policy
focussed on work can be subverted by the state of the job
market.
For example the 3 year freeze on child benefit means for a
family with two children according to the FPI is equivalent to £73
pa in 2011-12 rising to £192.32 pa in 2013-14. Such a loss is
particularly hard for those on low incomes, particularly those
defined as in poverty.
Because of the Church of England's intimate experience of all
the communities of the land, we have no option but to be sensitive
to the realities experienced by the most vulnerable and poor
families as economic policies and the cuts in welfare are
exacerbated by the cuts in services and support made by local
authorities. Whilst we recognise the government's sincerity in its
objectives, we expect policy to be fully informed by the real
experiences of all those whose lives will be affected. We are yet
to be fully convinced that the proposals do enough to meet needs of
the vulnerable, especially vulnerable children.
Notes:
1. On the 5th April 2011 the Government
published two strategies, Open Doors, breaking barriers: A
Strategy for Social Mobility and A New Approach to child
poverty: Tackling the causes of disadvantage and transforming
families' lives
2. The strategy on child poverty was published under the
requirements of the Child Poverty Act 2010, which received Royal
Assent on 25 March 2010.
3. It follows the consultation Tackling child poverty
and improving life chances: consulting on a new approach. For
MPA's response to this consultation see
http://www.churchofengland.org/our-views/marriage,-family-and-sexuality-issues/children/child-poverty.aspx