Reflections on the Porvoo Conference

10 October 2025
6 minutes read

The Porvoo Communion marked the 1700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea with a conference in Cardiff entitled “Theological Orthodoxy and the Ecumenical Journey: Learning from the Council of Nicaea.” 

The Porvoo Communion consists of the Anglican churches of the British Isles and a number of other episcopally-ordered reformed churches, mostly Lutheran churches in Scandinavia and the Baltic, but also the Lusitanian Church of Portugal and the Reformed Episcopal Church of Spain. All but the last of these was represented, giving perhaps a maritime as well as an ecclesiological connection. The sense of a wider ecumenical scope was ever present, as we were meeting in a former independent chapel now owned by the Catholic diocese, and the event included Catholic vespers and many participants from beyond the Porvoo churches. 

Spending a couple of days together, in a surprisingly sunny Cardiff, gave us the chance to learn more about each other’s traditions. We discovered the biggest cultural difference is in crossing the road! But it was also unsettling to hear about the real fear affecting those countries closest to Russia. We also discussed the ‘quiet revival’ amongst younger men in particular, which has not so far been observed in the Lutheran churches – but it was rather sweetly illustrated on the final night when three young guys in the street asked me if there was ‘some kind of vicar conference’ because they had ‘seen the former Archbishop of Canterbury, but we didn’t manage to get a photo’! 

 

Two men sat beside each other at a church event

 

The main ecumenical event of the conference was the admission of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of the Faroe Islands into the Porvoo Communion, which took place with great solemnity and joy during a service led by Archbishop Cherry Vann and attended by all the bishops on the Church in Wales, as well as a Faroese government representative. One speaker referred to it as the Council of Cardiff – a whimsical comment, but one which prompted reflection on how we are continuing in the conciliar legacy. More than one speaker also reminded us that it is the centenary of the 1925 Stockholm Conference which was a precursor to the World Council of Churches. 

The event was hosted by the Church in Wales, and the social and liturgical aspects of the conference showcased Welsh language and culture, including prayers from the Black Book of Carmarthen, a recital of harp music and songs from the ‘plygain’tradition of carol singing, and a visit to the Senedd. It was interesting to compare notes about the different structures and political culture of the Church in Wales, although English accents were notably overrepresented, not least the Liverpudlian bishop representing Sweden! The quality of the dinners and entertainment also set the bar very high for whoever hosts the next such event! 

A challenge in this anniversary year, already well endowed with conferences, was how to say anything new about Nicaea. The talks were split into three themes: Christology, Unity, and Legacy. The first keynote speech, by Catrin Haf Williams, brought us up to date on the academic debate around early Christology. Rather than seeing the Nicene Creed as a product of Greek philosophical thought, at odds with our faith’s Jewish roots, scholars now recognise greater continuity with New Testament, Old Testament, and intertestamentary language. Andrew Pierce from the Church of Ireland explored this further on the second day, and Tomi Karttunen from Finland introduced the idea that homoousios may be neither a philosophical nor a biblical concept but best understood doxologically, as an affirmation of ‘God with us’ – a theme which was picked up more fully later by Johan Dalmann from Sweden. Mark Clavier (Church in Wales) went beyond the language of the creed to the significance of the council. The very fact that a technical theological debate had political consquences requiring the attention of an emperor, and that it was solved by argument and vote, signifies that in Christianity “ideas matter” in a new way. 

It was in discussing the liturgical use of the creed that differences between the Lutheran and Anglican traditions emerged most clearly. Both Charlotte Methuen of the Scottish Episcopal Church and Mark Chapman traced how the Nicene Creed became the standard creed of the eucharist in the Anglican tradition, forming part of our worship and often our music (and, I would add from my own tradition, often incorporating physical gestures from the congregation). Yet Charlotte questioned whether we can describe ourselves as having a ‘Nicene faith’ as it is increasingly being replaced with confessions of faith which focus on the incarnation rather than the Trinity or the eternal existence of the Son. In the Lutheran tradition, the Nicene Creed is rarely recited, with the Apostles’ Creed being used much more. We discussed the pastoral use of the creed as something both more and less than a statement of shared faith: as a shared confession or act of allegiance; as a ‘map’ of the Christian faith which should encourage people to visit rather than to study the map itself; and as an ‘ingredients list’ which tells the newly baptised what they are buying into. Iceland’s Bjarni Thor Bjarnason suggested many laypeople no longer see the relevance of the Trinity to our salvation. But Rowan Williams gave us plenty of reason to place the Trinity at the centre of our faith, in a keynote speech on the continuity of ecclesiology and Creation. God as Trinity is God who is always in relationship, always creating, always self-giving, providing no basis to prioritise self-reliance and individualism. 

 

Event in a Church

 

Finally, we turned to problematising the Creed and the barriers it represents in ecumenism, inter-faith dialogue, and mission. We discussed the filioque clause, on which our churches have different practices, with the Scottish Episcopal Church having already stopped using it, and the Lutheran World Federation having recently agreed to drop it, in both cases with very little debate. Susan Durber turned around Mark Clavier’s earlier point, suggesting that Nicea marks the invention of heresy and the beginning of exclusion, with Jakob Wiren from Sweden highlighting early Christian antisemitism and observing that the definition of heresy gave Christians language to negatively define Jewish and Muslim beliefs. Susan also highlighed Nicaea’s association with imperial power which sits ill with WCC’s current focus on decolonisation. There was debate over whether Nicaea’s Christology can still be read as inherently anti-imperial, and how we should now relate to the legacy of Constantine. A point not explored is that Constantine remains most revered not in the former imperial powers of Western Europe but in the Orthodox world, most of which has experienced domination under non-Christian empires. 

Whether our ecumenical fellowship represents the triumph of conciliar spirit or a move away from the importance of ideas, it was warmly felt, and genuinely moving to welcome the Faroes.

Katherine Price