Bishop Sarah Mullally, the former Chief Nursing Officer for England, said she was concerned about those who could face internal and subtle pressures to end their lives if assisted suicide were introduced – particularly in the absence of adequate palliative or social care, or out of fear of becoming a burden on their families.
“I understand the fear of many that they may be offered free assisted death before they are offered the care and equipment that they may live,” she said.
As the Church of England's lead bishop for health and social care, the Bishop of London was speaking as the House of Lords began its first day of debate on the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill.
The Private Member’s Bill, brought by the MP Kim Leadbeater, completed its Third Reading in the Commons in June with a reduced majority of just 23 votes amid mounting concerns about its safety.
Bishop Sarah said it is right for peers now to scrutinise the Bill but argued that no amendments could ultimately make it entirely safe from the negative effects such as people being pressured to end their lives.
“I am concerned that the Bill is unequal to the task of preventing avoidable deaths due to the existing problems of discrimination, inequality and abuse.
“I am deeply concerned that so many in this Parliament are not heeding the voices of professional and representative bodies that are raising the alarm.”
She also rejected the central claim that the Bill would offer people choice at the end of their lives.
“A meaningful choice would see the measures in this Bill set alongside equally available, fully-funded palliative and social care services,” she said.
“Without the choice offered this choice is an illusion.”,
She spoke about her personal experience, including as a nurse, priest, and bishop, of spending time with people as they died and said the introduction of assisted dying within the health system would fundamentally alter the role of health professionals.
“To change the law is to change society,” she added.
“Any law that introduces choice for a few is not limited in its effect to only that few.
“If passed, this Bill will signal that we are a society that believes that some lives are not worth living.
“This Bill would become our State-endorsed position, and our NHS would be active in its delivery.”
Bishop Sarah also voiced hopes the Lords would have an opportunity to vote on the principle of the Bill at Third Reading – and indicated that she would be prepared to put an amendment at that stage to enable that to happen.
"It may not be the will of the House to take the decision on the principle of this Bill today, but I firmly hope that we will do that in the Third Reading. If it is necessary, I will table the amendment myself so this House is given the same opportunity as the other place to decide. Until then, I have no doubt that the scrutiny given to this Bill in the coming stages will make plainer its inadequacies," she said.
Speaking personally she concluded: “As we have heard, much of the debate is about fear. Fear of pain, of illness, of dependency, of loss of control, being somehow unrecognisable to yourself and to others. But the challenge is that life is not something to be managed or limited when it becomes difficult. Life is often more than we can ever understand it to be.
“I believe in a God who’s very being is life, and in that gift we can discover meaning, dignity and innate worth, even if we are dying.
“To speak of God is to speak of one who is never indifferent to human fragility, but who holds it and tends it.
“That is why I believe that there is always hope: hope that what looks like an ending is not the last word.
“Hope that with proper care, support and research, dignity and compassion is still possible. It is this firm belief that compels me to resist this bill.”
Read Bishop Sarah's full speech