Dame Christine Ryan, independent Executive Chair of the Safeguarding Structures Programme Board
Thank you, Bishop Joanne, and thank you members of Synod.
I want to speak today about the answer to a basic question:
Can the Church build a safeguarding structure that is trusted — by victims and survivors, by those doing safeguarding work day-to-day, and by the wider public?
That is what lies at the heart of the paper before you. For context, I want to offer three things for you to consider:
- what I have seen since taking up this role,
- why the current arrangements still leave you vulnerable to safeguarding failures,
- and what the proposal before you offers as a credible way forward.
I came into post last October, as someone who has spent much of my professional life in governance, regulation, and public accountability – I am not a member of this Church.
Since October, I have listened carefully.
I have spoken with survivors, safeguarding professionals, parish volunteers, staff and clergy at all levels, auditors, regulators, and parliamentarians.
I have read the many reviews, reports and their recommendations, and I have watched Synod debates.
My first observation is:
That this is a Church ready to change. There is deep commitment, and a real desire to do what is right.
You have deliberated carefully and thoughtfully, but have been too slow to act, and the outside world is no longer willing to wait. The window for phased change has closed.
The Charity Commission, survivors, Parliament, and the public are not looking for incremental adjustments. They are looking for a safeguarding system that is coherent, credible, and accountable.
Synod, my observations about the current system will not be new news.
First, be assured that there have been improvements in safeguarding over recent years, the reality is often better than the perception, but improvements are not uniform and they are not enough to restore trust.
At present, it remains the case that safeguarding is too often experienced as:
- overly complex,
- inconsistent,
- and lacking independence.
Accountability and oversight are dispersed and decision-making is sometimes unclear.
And the Church can find itself in the invidious position of being both pastor and judge in the most serious safeguarding matters. That is not sustainable, and it does not create confidence.
Most importantly, it inadvertently perpetuates a weakened safeguarding culture that could be vulnerable to exploitation and where poor practice might go unchallenged.
Good safeguarding is not assured only by structures and processes, it relies on having a culture where harmful behaviour is easily exposed, because everyone is aware. That is the culture change you must deliver. And that requires a system that people can trust.
My third observation is that the Church is a complex organisation, with many layers of responsibility and influence, but you are not unique in that complexity.
Other organisations have successfully navigated similarly complex reform. In safeguarding, complexity is risk and risk leads to mistrust. It is time to remove that complexity.
That is why I have realigned this work into a single unified vision.
I am confident that, with full commitment, the proposal can deliver greater independence, scrutiny, and consistency, and can do so whilst assuring local trustees that they can safely discharge their legal obligations. With your endorsement, we can deliver at pace meeting the expectations of external stakeholders.
Before I touch on the proposal itself, I want to turn briefly to governance.
We know, not least from the various failings and scandals that seem to fill our newspapers every day, that most organisational failures can be traced back to failures in governance and leadership:
Unclear accountability, blurred decision-making, and a lack of independent scrutiny. That is why I have strengthened governance of the Programme Board itself. We have moved to a majority-independent Board. With a number of individuals with lived experience of Church-related abuse included as full members.
The changes are not technicalities but the foundations of credibility for the work ahead.
Synod, the centrepiece of the paper before you is the creation of a new national charity — provisionally called the Independent Safeguarding Authority.
I will let the paper speak for itself, but I want to address four fundamental tensions that I have sought to resolve in order to strengthen safeguarding and to rebuild trust:
First: Independence and complexity.
Safeguarding decisions must be protected from real or perceived institutional pressure. The charity will be led by a Board that is majority independent of the Church and will have a Chief Safeguarding Officer whose professional safeguarding decisions are protected and externally overseen.
The authority will provide a centralised service, removing complexity from the safeguarding landscape.
Second: Pace and accountability.
We do not need to wait for legislation to act. This model drives compliance from the start through public accountability, whilst any necessary legal underpinnings are being enabled. It includes a uniform, transparent complaints process, that can begin operating this year.
Third: Trustee responsibilities.
Local trustees will remain responsible, as they must — but they are not left exposed. The Authority acts as a professional anchor, providing oversight, robust assurance, and due diligence support, so that trustees can be confident that they are fulfilling their responsibilities.
Fourth: People and expertise.
Your safeguarding staff and volunteers are a key asset. This is not about replacing them. It is about giving them a stronger professional home, with consistent standards, oversight, and improved resources, training and support that they would welcome.
Independence, consistency and reliability are how you begin to create the conditions for culture change.
The paper before you offers a strategic approach that builds on existing expertise, whilst inviting the external scrutiny and rigour that will make the Church a safer and more trusted place.
Synod, my ask today is simple: endorse this direction of travel. The cost of delayed action will be measured in the harm it enables and that is an unacceptable price.
Thank you.