Nine ways to improve your church email newsletter

10/04/2025

How can you optimise your church newsletter? Here are nine ideas for creating engaging emails that get opened and read.

A good church email newsletter keeps readers informed and builds trust between church leaders and the community. As not everyone will see an update on social media, it’s helpful to keep everyone in the loop with a useful newsletter. 
 
Think back to the most recent email newsletter you received. What made you open it and read to the end? Was it the enticing subject line, a desire to be in the know, or an awaited exciting update? Here’s nine tips to make the most of your church newsletter. 

1. Focus on your audience 

Start by considering what your community would like to know, rather than what you want to tell them. Which updates and events are most relevant to them? Avoid the trap of including everything in one newsletter – that can be overwhelming for readers - and instead, filter it down to three or four focused areas. 
 
You could take this one step further and create newsletters aimed at the different groups of people you communicate with, so that people only receive the information that is most relevant to them. If you do target particular groups, make sure you have people’s consent to receive these messages. How can you provide value to these specific groups? What would be relevant information for them? 

These more focused newsletters could be:  

  • A family-focused newsletter for parents e.g. you could share the latest events and support for parents and young people 

  • Updates for men’s groups or women’s groups e.g. when are the next social gatherings? 

  • News for people in small groups e.g. Bible/prayer/inspirational content 

  • A newsletter for volunteers in your congregation 

2. Subject lines, headlines and calls-to-action 

Entice readers to open the email with a catchy and short subject line, hinting at what’s enclosed. Try to keep this concise: the ideal subject line should be between 30 or 50 characters, or four to seven words in length. Throughout the newsletter, use short headlines to draw the reader's eye down the page and organise the different sections of the newsletter. 

Calls-to-action encourage the reader to take an action such as: ‘donate here’ or ‘book your ticket now’ or ‘learn more’. They’re a good way to engage people further (e.g. directing them to your website) and highlight what it is they need to do, e.g. if it’s a church weekend away, they need to ‘sign up here’. You can emphasise call-to-action links by making them into a button or clickable image which stands apart from the rest of the email. 

3. Make it easy to read 

Short, concise text will help get your message across, whereas long paragraphs can be off-putting and crucial details may be missed. Keep the most important information e.g. ‘the deadline for booking onto our weekend away is next week’ at the beginning of the relevant section. 

Break up blocks of text with bullet points, paragraphs and images. Use engaging rhetorical questions for a more conversational style e.g. ‘Have you read our latest blog?’. For your services and events, include the essential details or a short line of text, and a link to your website will enable interested readers to find out more.  

4. Be consistent 

Publish your newsletter regularly, monthly or weekly – whatever you have time for – but do keep it consistent so that readers know when to expect it. Regular features will create a consistent feel to the newsletter so your audience comes back for more. These could be features like: 

  • ‘What’s happening this month’ 

  • ‘Our latest blogs’ 

  • ‘Photo of the week’  

  • ‘Meet the team’ e.g. profile a different team member 

Free design tools such as Canva include varied and customisable templates to create simple and eye-catching email newsletters.  

screenshot of newsletter templates on canva

5. Provide something unique 

Be consistent, but also provide something unique! A surprise or new feature will encourage readers to open it, especially those who don’t often. You can also tease this surprise or new feature in the subject line of the newsletter to encourage people to open it. 

Use your services and events to highlight your newsletter, hinting at upcoming announcements to entice new people to sign up, and current subscribers to open it!  

6. Involve your community 

Are there members of your community with a story to share, and an interesting hobby or a thought for the day? Inviting your community to contribute to the newsletter will increase engagement and inspire a deeper sense of community amongst the readers. Here’s a case study of a church in Freiburg, Germany where their weekly newsletter promotes a reflective blog that members of the community contribute to. 

7. Use a newsletter tool 

If you like the idea of designing a layout, adding automation, or getting more advanced with audiences, organisation and scheduling, a dedicated newsletter tool may be for you.  

Mailchimp is a popular and intuitive tool, and includes numerous customisable design templates for you to explore (see an example of how its email builder looks below). You can get a free Mailchimp account (but this plan limits you to 500 contacts) or explore their paid plans get more features. You can also now integrate Canva with Mailchimp, so you can create designs in Canva and send them through Mailchimp easily. There are other email tools available – search online for 'free newsletter tools' and try a few out.  
 
A good tool will allow you to create a template to use each time, add images and video, customise text, schedule ahead and give simple reports such as how many people opened the email and clicked the links. The reports are especially helpful when you are trying something new and want to see the results. For example, you might be trying specific dates/times to email, or different types of subject line – these analytics can tell you what works best. 

screenshot of mailchimp's demo email builder

8. Try AI for content creation 

Generative AI can provide numerous ideas for your email content – for example you could ask your preferred AI tool (e.g. Microsoft 365 Copilot) to ‘write 10 engaging subject lines for this email’ – then paste the content of your email. Whether you use the AI results or not they can give you ideas and suggest things you hadn’t thought of, to help you get the subject line you want. If your newsletter tool allows A/B testing (where you send two slightly different versions of the same message to test the reaction), you could send different versions of a newsletter (e.g. test two different subject lines) and see which has a higher open rate (the percentage of email recipients who open the email). 

9. GDPR and Data protection  

It’s vital to adhere to GDPR, ensuring people’s data is secure and that they’re not being sent messages they don’t want. You must always include an easy option to unsubscribe. Advice on consent and managing data can be found on Parish Resources

Keep up to date with all things digital and join our Digital Labs newsletter.

Subscribe here