Guidance (Best practice)

Criminal Records

Author
Safeguarding
Published date
20 August 2026
Last updated
1 November 2026
Safeguarding guidance and best practice

Safer Recruitment and People Management: Criminal Records  

At a Glance- Must Do’s 

  • Parishes are not expected to assess criminal record information themselves. Where criminal record or serious safeguarding information is disclosed, advice must be sought from the diocesan safeguarding team (for example DSO/CSO) and followed.

  • Criminal record/police information may arise in a number of different ways for example via the CDF, a DBS certificate, or diocesan notification; whichever route, do not make an on-the-spot parish decision. 

  • Decisions about suitability are made case by case, based on the role, the information disclosed, and safeguarding risk -not on the existence of a criminal record alone. 

  • Keep brief, factual records that advice was sought, the decision made, and any conditions attached, and store securely with access limited to those who need to know.

Did you know?

  • Some cautions and convictions are legally spent or protected under criminal records law and must not be considered in recruitment decisions. Diocesan safeguarding teams will help you ensure this is handled lawfully. 
  • Where a Church body is Registered Body or receives DBS Update Service information, a written Recruitment of Ex-Offenders policy must be in place and used to guide fait decision-making.
  • Criminal record information may come to light after appointment as well as during recruitment. The same advice-seeking and recording approach applies in both situations. 

How To

Step 1: Note the disclosure and explain next steps 

  • Criminal record or other sensitive safeguarding information may come via a number of different routes, most often via the CDF, a DBS certificate, the application form or the diocesan safeguarding team. If you become aware of it: 

  • Thank the person (where appropriate) and acknowledge it may be difficult to share. 

  • Do not give an immediate yes/no decision; explain you must seek diocesan safeguarding advice. 

  • Reassure them the information will be handled confidentially and shared only on a need-to-know basis for safeguarding/safer recruitment. 

Step 2: Contact the diocesan safeguarding team promptly 

  • Parishes must not interpret or assess criminal record information themselves. 

  • Share only what is necessary (for example relevant sections of the CDF/DBS and a short role summary). 

  • Follow diocesan guidance on involving HR, registrars or senior staff for complex cases. 

Step 3: Follow diocesan advice and record the decision 

  • The diocesan safeguarding team will consider the information in line with: 

  • criminal records law (including the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act and DBS filtering rules), 

  • national Church guidance, and 

  • the nature of the role. 

  • They may use a formal risk assessment process and advise whether: 

  • the person can be appointed, 

  • the person can be appointed with conditions (for example supervision, restrictions, training), or 

  • the person should not be appointed. 

In the parish: 

  • Record that advice was sought, who was consulted and when. 

  • Record the decision and any agreed conditions. 

  • Store records securely, with access limited to those who need them for safer recruitment and people management.

Was this page helpful?