External reviews and reports about safeguarding in the Church of England.

The information on this page may be upsetting for some readers.

Support is available via Safe Spaces, a free and independent support service for anyone who has experienced abuse in relation to the Church of England, the Church in Wales, or the Catholic Church of England and Wales. 

You can contact the Safe Spaces team through their helpline (0300 303 1056), their live chat facility or by emailing [email protected].

Other support services are available. 

On this page you can find independent reviews and reports related to safeguarding in the Church of England. 

These reviews cover a range of safeguarding matters, from individual cases and specific Church contexts to wider questions about policy, culture and practice. At the heart of every review are people and their experiences. The reviews help the Church listen, learn and understand where change is needed.

Independent reviews and reports play an important role in strengthening safeguarding. They provide scrutiny, identify lessons to be learned and make recommendations that can help improve safeguarding across the Church.

Ongoing reviews

David Tudor review

The Safeguarding Practice Review (SPR) to look at the lessons to be learnt from the Church’s handling of the David Tudor case was jointly commissioned by the National Safeguarding Team and the dioceses of Chelmsford and Southwark in April 2025. 

Key documents: 

Terms of Reference

September 2026 update
The Safeguarding Practice Review Group, SPRG, has provided a further update on timings.  At their most recent meeting, SPRG members acknowledged the importance of providing timely clarity to victims and survivors. Given the continuing legal process and ongoing police investigation, members agreed to communicate at this stage that the final version of the review is not expected to be ready for publication until early 2027.
 

June 2026 update
The independent reviewers have completed the first draft of the Safeguarding Practice Review, SPR, relating to the David Tudor case. Survivors have been informed that it is now in the final process of due diligence, which includes the right of reply for all contributors. This is an important and necessary part of conducting the SPR process fairly, correctly and transparently.  The review, which was temporarily halted due to new police information, is expected to be ready for publication in the latter part of 2026. Contact with the police is ongoing and there will be further information on publication when the current process is near completion. Support continues to be offered to all the survivors the Church is in contact with.

November 2025 update
The David Tudor Safeguarding Practice Review, commissioned by the National Safeguarding Team, NST and the dioceses of Southwark and Chelmsford, has extended beyond the initially planned six-month deadline due to new police information. It is now expected to be completed in the early part of 2026. Survivors have been updated on this and support continues to be offered.

 
September 2025 - final call for evidence
The Safeguarding Practice Review (SPR), jointly commissioned by the National Safeguarding Team and the dioceses of Chelmsford and Southwark to look at the lessons to be learnt from the Church’s handling of the David Tudor case, is drawing to a conclusion. The independent reviewers Sue Williams and Richard Norfolk have asked that any final evidence to be submitted relating to the case should be done so by Friday 19 September.  Survivors have been informed of this update.  Please email the independent reviewers direct:
[email protected]
[email protected]
 
Original announcement April 2025
A Safeguarding Practice Review (SPR) has been jointly commissioned by the National Safeguarding Team and the dioceses of Chelmsford and Southwark to look at the lessons to be learnt from the Church’s handling of the David Tudor case.
 
David Tudor, a former Rector in Chelmsford Diocese, was prohibited from ministry for life in October 2024 following two complaints under the Clergy Discipline Measure. The penalty imposed followed a full admission of guilt to disclosures of serious sexual abuse from the two complainants, relating to the time when he was a priest in the Diocese of Southwark.

As the House of Bishops guidance (Code) states, a SPR is a process to improve safeguarding practice through learning, particularly outcomes for victims and survivors. It is not a re-investigation of the case but if the review highlights serious safeguarding concerns relating to the practice of others then appropriate action will be taken under the Responding guidance.

The SPR will examine the allegations against David Tudor, how the Church handled them over a long period of time and how it responded to victims and survivors.

The reviewer will then apply the learning from this to improve practice and safeguarding arrangements in the Church of England, these findings will be contained in the final report which will be published.

As per guidance an independent reviewer with relevant expertise and experience has been appointed.  Sue Williams, a former Commander in the Met Police has now started work, and the Terms of Reference have been agreed with the advisory group overseeing the process, made up of safeguarding professionals, an independent panel member and includes input from victims and survivors. Sue Williams will be assisted by former senior police officer Richard Norfolk.

Reviews and reports 2020-present

Review from thirtyone:eight on the case of TT (2026)

An independent review of the Church's handling of the case of TT, commissioned from thirtyone:eight, focusing on the response to allegations of rape, sexual abuse and spiritual abuse by two clergy youth officers (July 2026).

Full review of the Church's handling of the case of TT - download

John Smyth review by Keith Makin (2024)

An independent review, by Keith Makin, of the Church’s handlings of allegations against the late John Smyth.

 

Soul Survivor review by Fiona Scolding KC (2024)

In November 2023 the Trustees of Soul Survivor festivals, Soul Survivor Watford, and Soul61 (collectively known as Soul Survivor) commissioned Fiona Scolding KC to conduct an Independent Review into the culture and practices of Soul Survivor, following the National Safeguarding Team’s investigation into Mike Pilavachi. 

Full Review by Fiona Scolding KC

Executive Summary

Statement from Soul Survivor in response of review

Future of Church Safeguarding report by Professor Jay (2024)

A report by Professor Jay, the former Chair of the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, IICSA, with proposals around independence in safeguarding in the Church. 

Trevor Devamanikkam review by Jane Humphreys (2023)

A review by Jane Humphreys of the Church’s handling of allegations against the late priest Trevor Devamanikkam relating to sexual abuse of a 16-year-old in 1984 and later disclosures to senior figures. 

Related news articles

Trevor Devamanikkam review published
Review of Trevor Devamanikkam case

Fr Alan Griffin review by Chris Robson (2022)

The Diocese of London published an independent review by Chris Robson into the handling of allegations described by Coroner Mary Hassell in her Regulation 28 Report (July 2021) to the Church in relation to the death by suicide of Fr Alan Griffin.

William Scott Farrell review by Chris Robson (2022)

An independent overview report of the recruitment and appointment at three cathedrals of William Scott Farrell, who was convicted of sexual offences while employed in two, with concerns raised at a third. 

News release including statement from the independent reviewer and from the lead safeguarding bishop.

Graham Gregory Review by Ray Galloway (2022)

A lessons learnt review into the handling of allegations in five dioceses relating to the late Graham Gregory, priest. 

News release including statement from the independent reviewer and from the lead safeguarding bishop on the publication of the Graham Gregory review. 

Bishop Whitsey Review by David Pearl (2020)

A Betrayal of Trust (2020), the independent report by his honour David Pearl into the Church's handling of the allegations concerning the late Hubert Victor Whitsey, former Bishop of Chester. 

News release including statement from the independent reviewer and from the lead safeguarding bishop on the publication of the Bishop Whitsey review. 

Reviews and reports pre-2020

Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) 2018-2023

The Anglican Church in England and Wales was one of 15 investigations being looked at by IICSA, the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse. There were three hearings and two reports, including a number of recommendations, for the Church of England. 

Key reports and documents

Timeline

August 2023

January 2023

October 2022

July 2022

February 2022

September 2021

May 2021

March 2021

October 2020 - publication of overarching report from the Anglican Church investigation

May 2019 - publication by IICSA of an interim report into the Chichester and Peter Ball case studies.

April 2018 - IICSA published a wider interim report into its work

Hearings

March 2018 - Diocese of Chichester case study
July 2018 - Bishop Peter Ball case study
July 2019 - wider hearing into Church of England and Church in Wales

Documents and transcripts from the hearings

Bishop Peter Ball review by Dame Moira Gibb (2017)

An independent review by Dame Moira Gibb into the Church's handling of the late Bishop Peter Ball case.

Kendall House review (2016)

Kendall House was a private children’s home for girls based in Gravesend, Kent. Until 1986, it was run and funded by the Church of England, overseen by the Joint Council for Social Responsibility for the Dioceses of Rochester and Canterbury. Girls who were placed there were aged between 11 and 16 years

Full review into Kendall House by professor Sue Proctor, Ray Galloway and Samantha Cohen

Extension to the Kendall House Review

Statement from lead bishop on safeguarding

 

 

Elliot Review (2016)

An independent review by Ian Elliott into the historic abuse by Rev A of Survivor B. 

Full independent Elliott review

Response from the Bishop of Crediton, Sarah Mullally